I am a regular viewer of Idea Star Singer Season 5. I like this programme more than any other in asianet. When this programme started in 2010, it was very beautiful to watch with the wonderful panel of judges – Sarath Sir, Sri kumar Sir and Chitra madam – interacting with the contestants and correcting their mistakes. It was a visual treat to the eye and very soothing. But of late, the value has come down. the third judge Anuradha madam is not at all doing justice to the contestants. She is very partial and biased.Music is divine and only when it is imparted in an impartial atmosphere can I or any one can enjoy it to the fullest and we get satisfaction out of it. The fourth judge, Mano sir is also the same like Anuradha. There is no ethics in his distribution of marks. It is high time to remove these two judges and select some Malayalee singers to this panel. So we hope from the next stage onwards, we can listen to some great singers who occupy the eminent jury panel.
One more line to add – Ranjini as anchor is outstanding. Excellent. Keep it up.
Mrs.Anuradha is an excellent judge rather then others in the jury panel.
she always given absoluetly marks according to the perfection and quality of the song….nothing else and she is
having excellent know-how about music..
i am really surprise how some body…. given blame to her !!!!!!!!!!!! so sad………..
we too watching, since 2010
we are watching this progremme only because of Kalpana’s performence….. awesome……!!!!!!!!
Shabeer and Emmanuel doing excellent and leading this round..results are turning aound and I do hope ‘singing’ will win over ‘drama and other gimmic performances’. Its very hard to find best 5 out of them, will have to watch out!
Mrs.Anuradha is an excellent judge rather then others in the jury panel.
she always given absoluetly marks according to the perfection and quality of the song….nothing else and she is
having excellent know-how about music..
i am really surprise how some body…. given blame to her !!!!!!!!!!!! so sad………..
we too watching, since 2010
we are watching this progremme only because of Kalpana’s performence….. awesome……!!!!!!!!
i dont think so…..she gave un deserved mark to some contestant….specially to kalpana
yesterady kalpana stopped her singing and she got 82 mar(deserved only minimum mark) and CJ gave 9 mar….wt is this….anu maadn koduthu 26..ethinonnum oru kanakkum maanadandavumillee…..ethinaa engane okke cheythu ee showyude vila kalayunnathu…..
mridula nannayi perform cheythappol CJ koduthu 7 only…shame shame….
best of luck for all contestants for grand finale and also for judges…….manu y r soo good this stage,keep going on,may god bless you my chootu brother…….bindhu from bahrain….
Sooraj/Thambi, Shabeer has got an offer for a song in Sharath’s upcoming project. Great AR Rehman’s team too contacted him yesterday and couple more projects in his way. Hope u all will support him …
Dear Shabeer,
We cannot accept that you are out from grand finale of idea star singer season 5, You also one of the more talented star singer and do not lose your confidence as we want you in music industries long time also don’t follow the MG Sreekumar instruction in Music because he is not sincere on you he played the games and tried to put you out of the show. There is no doubt you can do much better than MG sreekumar in Music
We around 300 audiences or more contacted email and decided to not watch idea star singer grand finale.
Good bye Idea Star Singer season 5
Dear Shabeer,
Congrats! You are star singer not in idea. I think you have very good worldwide supporters.
Yesterday my mom cried when shabeer was out of the show and same time switched off the TV as she likes feelings his song very much, I send email comments to 10 friends through software if it is likes/support the comments, they will also send to their friends in this way till now 1098 family supports of shabeer it means 1098 email supports will not watch grand finale of idea star singer season 5.
SHABEER is the most talented Star singer of any season without any doubt which had been agreed by Najeem arshad who has been stood as a winner in the second season. I will not blame the judges but it was predetermined by the management, the result was known to the contestant before they were going to sing, what a pitty. Chitra, Sarath n MGS were also sad about the decision but all they could do was open their heart and praise him to be the real star, i believe they did it. ISS is not only run by them there lot of people behind it, believe me ‘Regionilism n relegionism plays a big role’. If antony is poor shabeer was the poorest n from a very low profile family why didn’t they consider him? If Kalpana sings well Shabeer is twice better than her. We ever cannot justify their decision which is worst ever in any reality shows, SHABEER is the most applauded singer by any musicians, see you cannot hide the fact…He is fantastic n excellent singer no one can degrade him..SHABEER you live in our heart….You are the real STAR SINGER for us……You are the only singer who is going to get appreciated out of ISS in a very nearest future…..YOU ARE THE BEST…..A National award is on your way…..
.
#1 by omana on August 20th, 2011
| Quote
Dear Asianet:
I am a regular viewer of Idea Star Singer Season 5. I like this programme more than any other in asianet. When this programme started in 2010, it was very beautiful to watch with the wonderful panel of judges – Sarath Sir, Sri kumar Sir and Chitra madam – interacting with the contestants and correcting their mistakes. It was a visual treat to the eye and very soothing. But of late, the value has come down. the third judge Anuradha madam is not at all doing justice to the contestants. She is very partial and biased.Music is divine and only when it is imparted in an impartial atmosphere can I or any one can enjoy it to the fullest and we get satisfaction out of it. The fourth judge, Mano sir is also the same like Anuradha. There is no ethics in his distribution of marks. It is high time to remove these two judges and select some Malayalee singers to this panel. So we hope from the next stage onwards, we can listen to some great singers who occupy the eminent jury panel.
One more line to add – Ranjini as anchor is outstanding. Excellent. Keep it up.
#2 by hunhu on August 23rd, 2011
| Quote
what a bad show please stop it
#3 by Er.P.M.Anandam, UAE on August 24th, 2011
| Quote
All humbuck…….. how come Kalpana come in to the 9th rank!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
MG PURPOSLY CORNORING TO KALPANA….BETTER YOU all ELIMINATE kALPANA …
WE WILL STOP WATCHING iss-S 5
#4 by Meenakshi.S on August 27th, 2011
| Quote
Hi Kalpana we are your fan we are from Bangalore
we watch Idea Star singer only if you are there.All the very
best wishes.
#5 by joy on August 29th, 2011
| Quote
popularity stage show
#6 by joy on August 29th, 2011
| Quote
indias first meaga program
#7 by Akhil on August 31st, 2011
| Quote
Chithra chechi is the ony solution to improve the standard of judging. .Hope she will be able to make it for the finals.
#8 by Er.P.M.Anandam, UAE on September 1st, 2011
| Quote
Mrs.Anuradha is an excellent judge rather then others in the jury panel.
she always given absoluetly marks according to the perfection and quality of the song….nothing else and she is
having excellent know-how about music..
i am really surprise how some body…. given blame to her !!!!!!!!!!!! so sad………..
we too watching, since 2010
we are watching this progremme only because of Kalpana’s performence….. awesome……!!!!!!!!
#9 by Akhil on September 5th, 2011
| Quote
Fancy dress?Go and watch professional fancy dress.Better.
#10 by Shanavas on September 7th, 2011
| Quote
Shabeer and Emmanuel doing excellent and leading this round..results are turning aound and I do hope ‘singing’ will win over ‘drama and other gimmic performances’. Its very hard to find best 5 out of them, will have to watch out!
#11 by Shanavas on September 11th, 2011
| Quote
Hey, Whats the URL owner does? Almost everyone’s 5 stages are getting over, Please update the Marks………
#12 by SOORAJ on September 13th, 2011
| Quote
NOW A DAYS ALL THE JUDGES GIVING EXTRA MARK TO IMANUEL …. WT AN IDEA SARJII………….
#13 by SOORAJ on September 13th, 2011
| Quote
Type your comment here
i dont think so…..she gave un deserved mark to some contestant….specially to kalpana
#14 by SOORAJ on September 14th, 2011
| Quote
OHH MY GODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
yesterady kalpana stopped her singing and she got 82 mar(deserved only minimum mark) and CJ gave 9 mar….wt is this….anu maadn koduthu 26..ethinonnum oru kanakkum maanadandavumillee…..ethinaa engane okke cheythu ee showyude vila kalayunnathu…..
mridula nannayi perform cheythappol CJ koduthu 7 only…shame shame….
#15 by SOORAJ on September 15th, 2011
| Quote
ANURADHA GO BACK………..shame shame her mark awarding
#16 by Shan on September 16th, 2011
| Quote
“SHABEER…The future pride of Kerala” – Anuradha Sreeram
#17 by bindhu on September 17th, 2011
| Quote
best of luck for all contestants for grand finale and also for judges…….manu y r soo good this stage,keep going on,may god bless you my chootu brother…….bindhu from bahrain….
#18 by SOORAJ on September 17th, 2011
| Quote
All the Best Mridula for ur Grand finale Performance….Our support and pray always with uu…God Bless U……
#19 by SOORAJ on September 19th, 2011
| Quote
2day chithrachechi in elimination episode…..waww waw..wawwwwwwww
#20 by Shan on September 19th, 2011
| Quote
Sooraj/Thambi, Shabeer has got an offer for a song in Sharath’s upcoming project. Great AR Rehman’s team too contacted him yesterday and couple more projects in his way. Hope u all will support him …
#21 by SOORAJ on September 20th, 2011
| Quote
yes shan…shabeer got a chance from sharath sir…..mridula also got from sharath…she already sang and waiting for release….film name : MEKHAROOPAN
#22 by Anil A. on September 21st, 2011
| Quote
Dear Shabeer,
We cannot accept that you are out from grand finale of idea star singer season 5, You also one of the more talented star singer and do not lose your confidence as we want you in music industries long time also don’t follow the MG Sreekumar instruction in Music because he is not sincere on you he played the games and tried to put you out of the show. There is no doubt you can do much better than MG sreekumar in Music
We around 300 audiences or more contacted email and decided to not watch idea star singer grand finale.
Good bye Idea Star Singer season 5
#23 by Fahad on September 21st, 2011
| Quote
Hai iam fahad.this not riyality pleas stoped season 6
#24 by Fahad on September 21st, 2011
| Quote
Pleas tell shabeer sms?are u drama(asinet)
#25 by Anil A. on September 21st, 2011
| Quote
Dear Shabeer,
Congrats! You are star singer not in idea. I think you have very good worldwide supporters.
Yesterday my mom cried when shabeer was out of the show and same time switched off the TV as she likes feelings his song very much, I send email comments to 10 friends through software if it is likes/support the comments, they will also send to their friends in this way till now 1098 family supports of shabeer it means 1098 email supports will not watch grand finale of idea star singer season 5.
#26 by Shan on September 21st, 2011
| Quote
SHABEER is the most talented Star singer of any season without any doubt which had been agreed by Najeem arshad who has been stood as a winner in the second season. I will not blame the judges but it was predetermined by the management, the result was known to the contestant before they were going to sing, what a pitty. Chitra, Sarath n MGS were also sad about the decision but all they could do was open their heart and praise him to be the real star, i believe they did it. ISS is not only run by them there lot of people behind it, believe me ‘Regionilism n relegionism plays a big role’. If antony is poor shabeer was the poorest n from a very low profile family why didn’t they consider him? If Kalpana sings well Shabeer is twice better than her. We ever cannot justify their decision which is worst ever in any reality shows, SHABEER is the most applauded singer by any musicians, see you cannot hide the fact…He is fantastic n excellent singer no one can degrade him..SHABEER you live in our heart….You are the real STAR SINGER for us……You are the only singer who is going to get appreciated out of ISS in a very nearest future…..YOU ARE THE BEST…..A National award is on your way…..
.
#27 by SOORAJ on September 24th, 2011
| Quote
All The Best Mridula for ur Grand finale Performance
#28 by SOORAJ on September 25th, 2011
| Quote
CONGRATS MRIDULA………U R THE REAL WINNER OF ISS SEASON 5